Classic Key West Accommodations

Retreat to The Mermaid & The Alligator, where each of our sophisticated and stylish accommodations in Key West have their own unique story. Offering elegant furnishings, enchanting artwork, and luxurious amenities like Turkish bath towels and Egyptian cotton sheets, our lodging delivers a most restful and peaceful night’s sleep you will surely enjoy.

View Specials

Welcome to Key West

Tucked away amongst lush landscaping, you’ll revel in the beauty surrounding you. Large, mature shade trees, exotic plants, and an abundance of tropical birds will have you feeling as if you’ve arrived on your own personal island. Our lovely B&B boasts accommodations sure to fit every traveler’s individual style and needs.

Indulge in sophistication, class, and serenity at our circa 1904 Queen Anne Victorian mansion. Anything is possible at our adult-only property, a place that feels like home. Note: the check-in age for our property is 21.

Rooms and Suites with Style

In the Mansion: Boasting six stylish rooms on three floors, some of our Mansion Suites feature King beds and large spa-style bathtubs, while our other rooms have Queen beds and unique walk-in showers. Each of our hotel suites in Key West is uniquely decorated with its own distinct personality.

In the Garden Cottage: For a little more privacy, our Conch Cottage Rooms offer a laid-back and tranquil atmosphere amidst the M&A Gardens. Our historic 1880s cigar maker conch cottage features bright tropical colors and décor in the Bamboo, Papaya, and Key Lime Rooms. Access the cottage through our gardens and still enjoy all the amenities of the main house.

Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8

Caribbean Queen Suite Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

Escape for a romantic getaway to the Caribbean Queen Suite! Featuring all the luxurious amenities of a honeymoon suite, you can relax in the large Roman soaking tub, rest in the four-poster king bed, or watch the gentle breeze go through our garden from the wraparound veranda.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Safe
  • Soaking tub
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
  • Wraparound veranda
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage9

Treetop Suite Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

Nestled on the third floor, The Treetop Suite is aptly named for its view out across the neighborhood treetops. This private hotel suite in Key West features a King bed in one alcove and a large soaking tub open to the room in another with a private bath and shower. Hide away from the outside world in this tranquil suite! Note: The Treetop Suite is only accessible by a 40-step staircase.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Safe
  • Separate bath and shower
  • Soaking tub
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage9

Audubon Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

Inspired by the art of John James Audubon, the Audubon Suite boasts the original Dade County Pine paneled walls and floors from the original construction of the home. Unwind in the expansive bath area with a Jacuzzi bathtub and a large open shower. Step through French doors to our garden, patio, and pool area. This room is accessible from the ground floor and up the ramp from Truman St.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • French door access to patio
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Private entrance
  • Safe
  • Shower
  • Soaking tub
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8

Royal Poinciana Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

The perfect writer's retreat, Royal Poinciana allows you to pen your thoughts at the antique writing desk or become inspired while lounging on the outside veranda. Named after one of the stately trees in our garden, this luxurious suite includes a king bed and an elegant bath area with a marble shower and large mirrors.

Amenities:

  • Balcony
  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Safe
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
  • Shower
  • Veranda with Chaise Lounges and café table with seating
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8

Garden Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 Queen

Become one with the natural elements in our garden-themed room, boasting cathedral ceilings, a cool terra cotta floor, and a verdigris metal queen-size bed. The contemporary bath area features a large walk-in glass block shower with two showerheads and a glass roof. French doors open to a small deck leading to the grotto garden, patio, and pool area. This room is accessible from the ground floor and up the ramp from Truman St.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Outside access through French Doors
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Private entrance
  • Safe
  • Shower with two showerheads
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage9

Sun Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 Queen

Located in the bay portion of our Victorian home, this bright and airy second-floor room showcases a panoramic view into the trees through six-foot windows. Sunbathe directly through French doors opening onto a private sun deck overlooking the pool and garden. The private bath's step-in glass mosaic shower completes the room.

Amenities:

  • CD/AM/FM Radio
  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • French door access to patio
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Safe
  • Shower
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage2
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage3
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage4
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage5
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage6
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage7
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage8
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage9
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage10
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage11
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage12
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage13
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage14

Bamboo Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

A spacious ground floor room in our Conch Cottage, the Bamboo Room is tropically decorated with bamboo accents for a touch of casual sophistication. This peaceful room features an upholstered King bed and large sitting area with a bamboo thatch ceiling while the private bathroom boasts a slate floor and an oversized shower large enough for two.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Living room
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Porch with rocking chair and seating area
  • Private entrance
  • Safe
  • Shower with two showerheads
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1

Key Lime Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 King

Decorated with fresh tropical flair, The Key Lime Room is the perfect place to stay amidst the M&A Gardens and features a comfortable King bed and a private bath with a shower. Enter by walking through the main garden to the Conch Cottage's front porch, shared with the Papaya Room.

Amenities:

  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Porch with rocking chair and seating area
  • Private entrance
  • Safe
  • Shower with two showerheads
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info
Link to Larger Item Photo ListItemCarouselImage1

Papaya Room Occupancy: 2 | Beds: 1 Queen

Relax and unwind amidst tropical décor in the Papaya Room, featuring a Queen four-poster bed and a private bath with a shower. Tucked away in the Conch Cottage in the M&A Gardens, this Key West lodging option offers guests a private jungle escape with a shared front porch with the Key Lime Room.

Amenities:

  • CD/AM/FM Radio
  • Cotton sheets
  • Complimentary Wi-Fi
  • Tommy Bahama bath amenities
  • Hair dryer
  • Iron & ironing board
  • Living room
  • Luxury Turkish cotton towels
  • Multi-port electrical outlets
  • Cubietrio+ - wireless charging with USB charging ports and Bluetooth Music Play
  • Plush bathrobes
  • Porch with rocking chair and seating area
  • Private entrance
  • Safe
  • Shower with two showerheads
  • Sound therapy system
  • Synthetic down duvet & pillows
Book Now More Info