Welcome to the Florida Keys

The entire staff at The Mermaid & The Alligator has one goal: to make your stay as wonderful and memorable as possible. Supported by a detail-oriented, friendly, and caring staff, you can rest assured all your vacation needs will be met with a smile and a "can-do" attitude.

Guest FAQs

Our Story

We invite you to be our guest at our adults-only property. To retreat into our lovely, private, romantic, and comfortable B&B, where you can truly relax, unwind, and embrace the laid-back vibe that Key West is known for.


Marvel at the amazing amenities and accommodations found at our property, and know you are destined for a most memorable and lovely vacation. The proof is in the pictures.

M&A Gardens

Immerse yourself in beautiful tropical plants, and, depending on the migratory season, get to know the interesting birds that call The Mermaid & The Alligator their (temporary) home.